DigitalTenant
Free calculator

Should you rent or buy?

Compare the cost of renting with the cost of buying a home over the years you plan to stay. It counts mortgage payments, taxes, insurance, maintenance, equity and home value growth.

Free to useUpdates as you typeNo sign-up
All 12 calculators
calculators / rent vs. buy calculator
Renting may be better
$8,740
Saved by renting over 5 years
Total rent over 5 years$95,564
Net cost of buying over 5 years$104,304
Monthly mortgage$1,597
Monthly ownership cost$2,272
Equity built$121,866
Break even3 yrs
Price to rent ratio16.7
Renting saves you $8,740 over 5 years. Consider renting unless you value homeownership benefits beyond finances, or plan to stay longer. Price to rent ratio: Between 15 and 20, the market is neutral. Your decision should depend on personal factors and how long you will stay.
Next step
Renting next?

Tenant Passport lets you apply with one screening report you can reuse for other rentals.

What your result means

It depends on how long you stay.

Buying a home has big costs up front, like the down payment and closing costs, and more costs when you sell. Renting has none of those, but your rent usually goes up every year and you don't build equity.

This calculator adds up what you would spend each way over the years you plan to stay. For buying, it subtracts the equity you would have when you sell: your down payment, the part of the loan you paid off and any rise in the home's value.

The longer you stay, the more buying tends to make sense, because the up-front costs are spread over more years. If you might move in a couple of years, renting is often cheaper.

Example
  • Rent is $1,500 and goes up 3% a year. Over 5 years, you pay $95,564 in rent.
  • A $300,000 home with 20% down at 7% costs about $2,272 a month, with taxes, insurance and upkeep.
  • After 5 years, and after the costs of selling, buying comes to $104,304 once you count the $121,866 of equity you built.
In this example, renting saves you about $8,740 over 5 years.
In DigitalTenant

If you rent, a Tenant Passport lets you apply with one screening report and share it with more than one landlord while it's valid, so you don't pay for a new check with every application.

How it's calculated

The math, in plain words.

  1. 1Renting: add up a year of rent for each year you plan to stay, raising the rent each year by the expected increase.
  2. 2Buying: work out the monthly mortgage from the loan amount, rate and term, then add property tax, insurance, maintenance and HOA fees.
  3. 3Total the cost of buying over your stay: down payment, closing costs (assumed at 3% of the price), all monthly costs, and selling costs (assumed at 6% of the future home value).
  4. 4Subtract the equity you would have: the down payment, the loan principal paid off, and the growth in home value. The result is the net cost of buying.
  5. 5Compare the net cost of buying with the total rent. The lower one saves you money over your stay.
Ready when you are

Track these numbers for every property.

DigitalTenant keeps rent, expenses and every unit in one place, so your numbers stay up to date.